It may be that news stories are inaccurate, but as near as I can determine this is what happened:
Last Wednesday afternoon Rep. Cynthia McKinney went around metal detectors to enter the Longworth House Office Building in Washington, DC. Members of Congress are not required to pass through the detectors, although the congress critters are supposed to wear ID pins so the security guys will know who they are. And McKinney has admitted she wasn’t wearing her pin. In any event a Capitol police officer who says he did not recognize her and did not see any identification rushed to block her entrance.
After that it gets murkier. The cop says McKinney punched him in the chest. McKinney says the cop didn’t just block her; he also grabbed her, and she reacted to get him to turn her loose. McKinney also says the cop allowed her into the building after she showed him her ID. Allegedly this is all on surveillance tape, so eventually someone will look at the tape and determine who was at fault. Maybe they both were; maybe it was just a misunderstanding.
In any event, by Friday McKinney was claiming she was a victim of “excessive use of force” because she is an African-American woman. Harry Belafonte and Danny Glover stood with her at a press conference to offer their support. The President of NAACP Georgia said “The mistreatment of Cynthia McKinney at the hands of Capitol Hill Police is a tragedy of major proportion and points to the vigor of outright disrespect for women and people of color.”
This was too much for John Aravosis:
Yes, let’s cry racism and sexism and Democratism, I guess you’d call it, because a cop didn’t recognize you and you decided to not even wear your member of Congress pin, or turn around when the cop called out to you while we’re at war. Next time, it’ll be better if the cop lets strangers without their pins just barge into the halls of Congress, bypass security, and oh blow the hell out of the entire building because they’re afraid the person they stop might be – what? – a Democrat?
Today some of us lefties (example) are criticizing John for this post. Kevin Haden has accused John of “an elitism that knows no bounds.” Unfortunately the American Street page won’t build this morning, so I cannot read Kevin’s entire post to comment on it. Maybe later today.
But based on the facts as I understand them, I have to agree with Aravosis on this one. Seems to me it’s McKinney who’s being the elitist by assuming the rules don’t apply to her. Security personnel should not be asked to make judgments about who gets to break the rules and who doesn’t. In order to keep security systems fair and democratic — not to mention secure — everybody must abide by the same set of rules. If people with proper ID can bypass the metal detectors that’s fine; but if Ms. Big Shot forgets her ID, then she goes through the metal detectors. Even if the security people do recognize her. Even if she’s been in the bleeping House of Representatives since the charge up San Juan Hill.
McKinney did the wrong thing. It may be that we’ll learn the cop did use excessive force, but that doesn’t alter the fact that McKinney did the wrong thing by assuming she could sail past security without displaying an ID. This is true even if it turns out the security guys have been letting other people break the rules, in which case the whole operation needs to be tightened up.
We’ve learned the hard way in New York City that security personnel aren’t doing anyone any favors when they wave some people through security without checking them. The nice guy they’ve seen a hundred times, whose name they know, who has legitimate business in the building, could be carrying a .40-caliber Smith & Wesson handgun and have murder on his mind. It happens.
There’s no more effective way to weaken security than to give security personnel conflicting instructions, or to expect them to do a job (check people going into the building) but punish them for trying to do it (checking people who don’t want to be checked).
If you spend time in New York City or Capitol Hill, you get used to security checkpoints. There really are terrorists who would just love to blow up Congress or take out a major landmark. And there are people — they seem to gravitate to cities — who commit irrational acts of violence. This is a reality we must acknowledge, especially in a nation like ours that’s knee-deep in firearms.
I’ve heard the argument that because McKinney has been a good friend to progressive causes we should support her. But I say we don’t do progressivism any good by making excuses for the bad behavior of progressive leaders. When leaders think we’ll support them no matter what they do, they stop listening to us. Washington already is swimming with alleged progressive leaders who don’t listen to us. Our number one job these days is to get them to listen to us; to make them realize that we’re watching them and will hold them accountable. Nobody gets a pass. This is not to say that we won’t support them in the future if they do something good. I’m not saying we should drive someone out of the movement for one mistake.
Giving leaders a pass, on the other hand, is what righties do. Mike Leonard writes for the Indiana Times-Mail:
Former Indiana Rep. David McIntosh once scuffled with airport security guards after he bypassed metal detectors and hurried to board a commercial flight out of Washington. Politicians made that potentially criminal act go away by placing a gag order on airport security.
Former U.S. Rep. J.C. Watts parked in an unattended airport loading zone in a hurry to put his wife on a flight – post Sept. 11 – in Oklahoma City. He berated the attendant who ticketed his vehicle and then stuffed the citation under the officer’s badge and told him to “take care of it.”
It was unclear what made Watts more angry – that the attendant didn’t recognize him as a U.S. Representative or a former Oklahoma football star.
And then there was our own Rep. John Hostettler’s arrival at the Louisville airport with a gun in his attache case. A gun. Inside the airport. The congressman’s explanation was basically, “Oopsie!”
The Ho got probation – and lots of attention from late night comedians.
Are we supposed to be the mirror images of righties? I don’t think so. McKinney did the wrong thing. Let’s be grown-ups and admit it.