GOP Legislation Theater

Today House Republicans pulled a bill from the floor that was intended to embarrass Democrats and undermine the Affordable Care Act. Majority Leader Eric Cantor had sponsored the “Helping Sick Americans Now Act,” which

… would siphon $3.6 billion from the Affordable Care Act’s $10 billion prevention and public health fund, aimed at combating disease and promoting wellness, into an underfunded short-term plan to cover people with preexisting conditions until 2014, when the law will begin to ban insurers from denying coverage based on health status.

But the legislation doesn’t reflect a serious long-term effort to address the problem of sick Americans lacking access to health care or getting thrown off their insurance plan. It would shore up a costly and temporary high-risk pool under Obamacare — called the Pre-Existing Condition Insurance Plan — which expires at the end of 2013. Beyond that, Republicans continue to support repealing the rest of the Affordable Care Act, and lack economically feasible plans to address preexisting conditions.

Note that for years Republicans have promoted the idea of dumping people who need lots of medical care into high-risk insurance pools, so that people in the “normal” pool didn’t have to pay so much for insurance. The Affordable Care Act provided for something like that as a temporary fix until 2014, after which insurers can no longer refuse to insure people with pre-existing conditions. The problem is that the high-risk pools sucked up money the way a black hole sucks up matter, so that plan wasn’t really working. Naturally, that was the plan some Republicans decided to like.

However, other Republicans believed the bill would actually strengthen “Obamacare,” and who cares about sick people anyway? So it was scrapped.

The larger point is that the bill had absolutely no purpose except to give Republicans a bogus talking point to use against the President. Even if the Senate were to pass such a bill, the President would veto it. And then the GOP could say he vetoed a bill to help people with preexisting conditions, never mind that Obamacare actually does help people with preexisting conditions.

In other legislative theater news — Republicans have whined for some time that Democrats have not submitted a budget. Evan Soltas writes for Wonkblog,

For the last two years, congressional Republicans have argued that the real problem in the budget debate is that Democrats have abandoned “regular order.” By regular order, Republicans mean — well, I’ll let Sen. Jeff Sessions, the ranking Republican on the Budget Committee, explain it.

“Secret deals have not worked and are an affront to popular democracy,” he argued in January. “The right process is the regular order. The House produces its budget–as it has–and the Senate passes its budget, all in accordance with the Budget Act of 1974. Under that law, the Senate Budget Committee must approve a budget resolution by April 1st. From there, the law requires the budget to be considered on the Senate floor where it must receive 50 hours of open amendment and debate. A budget cannot be filibustered and is adopted by a simple majority in both committee and the full Senate. Then, once the issues and differences are clarified by this open process, the work of conferencing must begin.”

Soltas writes that “regular order” became a sacred totem among congressional Republicans. Well, until the Senate Democrats passed a budget. Now Republicans want to scuttle “regular order” in favor of backroom deals.

2 thoughts on “GOP Legislation Theater

  1. DC Political-Entertainment Review:
    Ah, watching “The New Republicans” perform “Regular Order” with the new line-up in their act, makes one nostalgic for the mid-00’s, when the older version of this improv group was doing, “UP OR DOWN VOTE!” in their show back then.

    Maybe it’s me, but some of us kind of prefer the faux-pathos of these scattered, but effective, “The Republican Vaudeville of Cruelty” sketches, to what the group did in between.
    But we have admit, we never thought that Americans could perform the tragicomedy that was the “DC Kabuki Theater Of the Absurd” acts, as effectively as they did in the intervening years.

    But the sense is, that at least half of the audience, while laughing and applauding as their beloved actors mock the other half of the audience in their shows, is oblivious to the message that is being sent by these performances.

    There is ample reason for concern, that the same people laughing and applauding now, will be shocked and stunned if rumours of their upcoming new show, “Representative Democratic Government is Dead, So Let’s Give Plutocratic Nihilism A Shot, Eh!” is true.

    The same “The New Republicans” fan base, which loved the tragicomedy of “DC Kabuki Theater Of the Absurd,” and adores the faux-pathos of “The Republican Vaudeville of Cruelty” sketches, will feel like the victims of a cruel hoax when their beloved group turns on the whole audience and mocks them, and the result is that at the end of the show, everyone will end up in the streets, defenseless, scared, and alone, while the performers happily return back to their homes, eager to collect their wages from their backers.
    Drama, tragedy and comedy are easy. Governing, is hard.

  2. http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/house-gop-leadership-young-guns-near-showdown-on-health-vote/2013/04/24/c0fbfa50-ab90-11e2-b6fd-ba6f5f26d70e_story.html?wpmk=MK0000200

    Now this is telling. So, per Norquist, the ONLY thing the House GOP should be doing regarding healthcare is passing bills to dismantle the ACA. Nothing to actually help anyone.

    And notice how Norquist is looking at whipped puppy Cantor in that picture. He’s clearly annoyed and not happy. If looks could kill…

    “Cantor pulled the bill after trying to push his rank-and-file members to support it during a closed-door huddle on Wednesday. He argued that ‘helping the sick people’ was a worthy conservative cause. ‘This is the right thing to do,’ Cantor said. ‘We’re trying to find solutions here.’”

    That hasn’t been a “worthy conservative cause” in decades.

    Cantor sure was naïve. And when he talked about “helping sick people” and “finding solutions” in that meeting, I can’t imagine that he didn’t hear the laughter it must have received.

    “Cantor, 49, and House Majority Whip Kevin McCarthy, 48, have often been described as tea party leaders in Congress, part of the younger GOP generation that recruited the rabble-rousing class of 2010 that thrust Republicans into the majority. Increasingly, however, conservative activists have signaled uneasy relations with the younger leaders”

    The “Young Guns”…that’s the payback they get for getting them in congress.

    LOL, they’re only comfortable with old white men, the more bigoted and ignorant, the better. They’re not trying to help anybody, not even they’re own.

Comments are closed.